peta's energies misplaced

topic posted Fri, August 22, 2008 - 10:48 AM by 
Share/Save/Bookmark
If peta were to spend all it's extremist energy on human causes, the animals would have less to worry about.
posted by:
  • Unsu...
     

    Re: peta's energies misplaced

    Fri, August 22, 2008 - 12:02 PM
    Okay Mickey, so what exactly do YOU do for human causes?
    • Unsu...
       

      Re: peta's energies misplaced

      Fri, August 22, 2008 - 12:07 PM
      And why would you join a group just to put what they do down?

      I see vegetarianism used as cancer prevention, diabetes prevention, and promoting a better relationship with other species to BE a human cause.

      but why not criticize Amnesty international for not fighting global warming.

      or criticize greenpeace for not fighting homelessness.

      or Mothers Against Drunk Drivers for not helping with children itteracy.
      ???
      there are many causes and each organization focus on their own.

      The PEOPLE (those are humans by the way) for the Ethical Treatment of Animals focus on...quel surprise! the ethical treatment of non-human animals.

      if you don't feel that it is a worthy cause, then don't support it. Support another one.

      but again, which causes do YOU support Mickey?
    • Re: peta's energies misplaced

      Fri, August 22, 2008 - 1:56 PM
      Thank you for that excellent question. I have worked in the nonprofit sector for almost a decade, working with children and youth, my Habitat for Humanity, a technology nonprofit designed to help other nonprofits build capacity, and an organization that fights bullying and intolerance. And those are the ones where I've been an employee, not to mention the ones I serve as a volunteer or board member. All of them show that within their mission-specific work, when you solve human problems, animal problems virtually disappear.
      • Unsu...
         

        Re: peta's energies misplaced

        Fri, August 22, 2008 - 2:10 PM
        how does fighting bullying and intolerance end animal abuse?
        How does helping youth and providing habitat to worthy people help to promote the vegan lifestyle?

        The point is Mickey that your "volunteering" is very vague and doubtful. But even if it were true that you DO help humans and society, why should PETA do what other organizations are already doing? do you hold other organizations to the same yardstick, or do you just like trolling animal rights activists?

        How would you react to someone who came to you, while you are running your youth anti-bullying program and said to you, why aren't you fighting global warming? yeah fighting global warming is a good cause, but right now i'm helping these kids....

        yeah humans have a lot of problems, but the People for the Ethical Treatment for the Animals help animals (and have to put up with idiots like you who think that they are qualified and justified to tell them how to spend their energies)

        it's not so much that it is annoying and insulting, but it is beside the point.
        yes we need to fight global warming, and so there are groups and orgs who do that.
        yes we need to help abused women, and children and there are groups and orgs that do that.
        yes, we need to build homes for the homeless and the poor and there are yet other groups who do that.
        etc...
        etc...
        etc...

        i would never judge that the work of say the salvation army is less worthy than the work of the HSUS, or that the work of doctor's without borders is less or more wortwhile than the work of say, amnesty international.

        the point is that there are many orgs and groups out there. find the one that you like and support them.

        now don't get me wrong, over the years i have found Peta VERY open to feedack...but you have to ask yourself is my criticism constructive and/or helpful?

        is it helpful to ask Peta to focus on human animals?

        what do you think?
        suggesting that they handle a campaign differently, may be useful, but asking them to do campaigns on completely other things? useful?

        well let's see:
        if you walk into a pasta and pizza place and suggest that they serve gellato is thta helpful? maybe.
        what if you walk in and ask that they sell hammers and screws? is THAT helpful?

        and what would they say? if you argue with them and say, people NEED hammers and screws! :-)

        ;-)

        it is entirely idiotic to expect that a group called the people for the ethical treatment of ANIMALS should tackle human bullying, or build homes for the poor. and you are obtuse if you don't understand why.
        • Re: peta's energies misplaced

          Fri, August 22, 2008 - 2:18 PM
          Hi Antoine! Well said.
          • Unsu...
             

            Re: peta's energies misplaced

            Fri, August 22, 2008 - 2:26 PM
            hi Erika. thanks. :-)
            every year or so we get a douchebag like this on this tribe or the animal rights tribe...

            what i wonder is do other tribes have to deal with this kinda crap?
            does the tennis enthusiasts tribe have people every year or so coming onto their tribe JOINING to post that tennis is waste of time?
            'that someone who DISLIKES or even hates Peta would join, JUST to post something against Peta, is mind-boggling to me.

            there are meat lovers tribes out there and even anti-vegan tribes, but I don't join them, just to tell off the members (although i would be more justified to do that because those tribes only exist to spread negativity while Peta is about promoting compassion kindness and well...ethical behaviour.)
            • Re: peta's energies misplaced

              Fri, August 22, 2008 - 2:48 PM
              I guess some folks just enjoy creating a bit of drama when they can, seems like the energy could be put to better use but, human nature and all that. :) Well worded answers (as yours ) will most likey keep it small, and thoe of us who are here know why, let the drama lovers create there on tribe and while away there time with each other! enjoy your weekend!
              • Re: peta's energies misplaced

                Sat, August 23, 2008 - 5:05 AM
                For the record, no personal insults were part of this thread until Antoine uttered the word "douchebag." He took us there. I will bring us back.

                I am not trying to say that fighting for animal rights is a worthless cause. I am trying to say that peta has likely outlived its usefulness, possibly even becoming an organization which does more damage than help.

                Fixing a human problem always helps a whole host of problems in ripple effect. To use two specific examples: Habitat homes are proven to reduce crime, their homeowner education helps them become better consumers, and their homes are more environmentally sound than the slums most homeowners are graduating from. Getting a family into decent housing puts them in a position to take better care of their pets. And independent studies show that yes, as crime rates in Habitat neighborhoods decrease, so does the incidence of animal cruelty or neglect. They take care of their neighborhoods, cleaning up streams, and in turn, volunteering for other environmental causes.

                Anti-bullying efforts decrease violence, improve self-esteem, and improve critical thinking skills which helps on way too many social causes. A bullied person is something like twenty times more likely to abuse animals. Take away the bullying of the human, and the bullying of the animal disappears, too. In each and every case, no matter the nonprofit or their specific niche missions, taking care of basic human causes has wide and far-reaching ripple effects that just happen to include making the world better for animals, and taking care of the world, in general. It very clearly is taking care of two or more problems with one simple effort.

                BTW, peta doesn't think you should have pets. Considers that animal slavery. Do you have pets?

                We will unfortunately need SPCA type organizations and humane societies for a long time, though I'm sure all of us wants to see them become obsolete. (Indeed, I would like someone to tell me that there is empirically no more need for anti-bullying programs or no longer any families living in poverty conditions.) Those useful organizations need financial and volunteer support. I don't think peta is among the "useful."

                And if working with a nonprofit is something like making a social investment, it seems very clear that the investment of volunteer hours or dollars in human-related social causes has a much bigger bang for the buck overall. Why just help animals when you can help humans and animals all at once?
                • Unsu...
                   

                  YOUR energies misplaced

                  Sat, August 23, 2008 - 10:47 AM
                  AGAIN : If you do not like Peta than DON'T SUPPORT THEM.
                  and definitely don't join a PeTA tribe.

                  Now, as for YOU thinking that PeTA how's outlived its usefullness, that is your opinion and it is a bad one.

                  What you say about habitat and anti-bullying, is a HUGE stretch.
                  Considering that the #1 abuse to animals is animals raised for food...over 10 billion land animals are killed every year for food in the US alone, if you factor in sea animals and the animals killed all around the world the number is closerr to 60 BILLION.

                  60 BILLION animals raised and tortured and slaughtered for food !!!! and providing nice homes for people and teaching them not to be bullies will not stop them from eating meat and other animal products.

                  You are correct about one thing though: the connection between violence on our plate and violence in the world.

                  Everyone says that they want Peace on Earth but no one suggests how. Vegetarianism will lead to peace on earth. This idea is not new. Pythagoras believed it, ditto for Gandhi and many others.

                  As long as we kill to feed ourselves everyday, it will always be easy for us to kill others. As a bit of a transformation of what Isaac Bashevis Singer said , in relation to animals ALL humans are bullies.

                  What many meat-eaters do not realize is that eating meat and other animal products is not a passive choice as in: I choose the vegetable burger, you choose the beef burger...it is an ACTIVE PREJUDICE. Because it means that you want the cow to die for you. Even worse you don't even care that the cow died.

                  to eat meat is to HATE animals. And that is what people do not realize. If you were to ask someone if they hate cows, most would say no that they do not HATE cows. Yet they want the cow to die. So either they HATE the cow or they are psychopaths who kill without emotions.
                  If you want someone to die for you, that is pretty powerful hatred. And if the only reason why you do not feel it is hatred is because you do not see them as a person, you see them as not deserving of your compassion or mercy, than that is PREJUDICE.

                  and considering that there are 60 billion animals dying each year, Mickey, I don't think that Peta has outlived its usefullness.
                  and how arrogant of you to suggest it especially HERE in a PeTA tribe.

                  considering that cancer, heart disease and diabetes and obesity are ALL on the rise, and are ALL human diseases caused by meat and and other animal products consumption, I don;t think that PeTA has outlived its usefullness

                  considering that our planet is VERY QUICKLY running out of clean drinking water and that 70 % of all water is poured down the throats of animals raised for food, and that over 50% of our water supplies are being polluted by the aniaml industries (leather, fur, meat, dairy, wool, eggs, etc) I don't think that PeTA has outlived its uselfulness.

                  considering that over 60% of the grain grown in the world is fed to animals raised for food, that 90% of the rain forests are cut to make way for grazing land for animals, and farm land to grow soy and corn to feed TO animals, that the U.N. has declared that animal industries are the #1 cause of global warming and that during all this time HUMAN CHILDREN are starving....(the perfect example of this is grain grown in Africa and not fed to the children of africa (who are starving) but instead shipped to Europe to feed animals!!!

                  I think that PeTA's energies are very well placed.

                  And I think that arrogant meat-eaters like you who take it upon themselves to say that they care MORE about humans need to realize that their steak does more AGAINST humans then anyhting else that they do.

                  When our grandchildren have no more land, water or clean air, you can tell them that you decided that spending your time educating people against bullying was more worthwhile.

                  As for you being a douchebag. you are.
                  It is not an insult it is a fact. People like you are the reason why the term douchebag exists.

                  Again, what you need to ask yourself is this: how usefull and helpful is my feedback?
                  like the analogy I gave earlier of suggesting that a restaurant sell hammers and nails. Not so much.
                  No one will argue that hammers and nails are not useful, but no one (except a TOTAL DOUCHEBAG) would expect a restaurant to sell hammers and nails.

                  habitat for Humanity is a great organization. Anti-bullying organizatiosn, and kid's help phone and all those kind of orgas are also good. But why does that eman that PeTA is innefective?

                  I never said that anti-bullying programs are not useful, but for you to amke the leap that their usefullness proves that PeTA is not useful???

                  And you are obviously NOT a PeTA member nor someone who even remotely likes peta, judging from the completely uninformed and idiotic comments that you made about pets. so on top of being a douchebag you are also a troll.

                  Or ask yourself, did I join this tribe because I like PeTA (as the description of the tribe suggests) and I want to have a conversation with my fellow PeTA members and perhaps share ideas about Peta actions?

                  considering what you said about "pet" animals, this is not the case at all. You ONLY joined this tribe to speak up AGAINST PeTA, so YOU ARE A TROLL.
                • Unsu...
                   

                  Re: peta's energies misplaced

                  Sat, August 23, 2008 - 10:58 AM
                  Okay and in case you actually want to educate yourself:

                  PeTA's position on pets is simple. Animals are not here to entertain us, so they are not "pets" they are companion animals.
                  In the LONG TERM the goal is to eventually to end all aniaml mdomestication (which would include even companion animals)
                  In today's society there are many animals abnadoned in shelters. Shelters are forced to kill thousands upon thousands of animals each day. Even PeTA themsleves often have bo other choice but to euthanize animals because there is no home for them, and if they were left in the shelter they would be killed or gassed or worse, or left in somebody's backyard to slowly starve to death.

                  And yet people keep breeding animals and keep sellign animals.

                  So it is OUR RESPONSIBILITY to adopt as many animals as we can (because we created the problem)
                  It is also our responsibility to spay and neuter these animals to amke sure that the population does not grow even further.

                  one could argue that spaying and neutering is a violation fo the aniamls basic rights, I would agree, but in this case, it is necessary for the greater good.

                  the first step is spay and neuter programs.
                  the second step is to stop all breeding of animals
                  and then the final step would be that eventually as generations of companion animals die of natural causes, there would be no more animals in shelters, and the only cats and dogs left would be wild, like squirrels and racoons.

                  I have three cats that live with me and my wife and I also volunteer with a spay and neuter catch and release program for feral colonies (and by the way PeTA does not support catch and realease programs they rather support catch and adopt or ethanize programs, but that is one point on which PeTA and I disagree, I have a mind of my own, and do not need to agree with everything that PeTA says to support them.)

                  YOU however obviously agree with NOTHING that Peta says, and you don;t even UNDERSTAND the message of PeTA as demonstrated by your UNBELIEVABLY ignorant comment about pets, so why are you here?

                  I would suggest that you go to the PeTA website and educate yourself. www.peta.org
                  • This is the maximum depth. Additional responses will not be threaded.

                    Re: peta's energies misplaced

                    Thu, August 28, 2008 - 1:20 PM
                    "As for you being a douchebag. you are.
                    It is not an insult it is a fact. People like you are the reason why the term douchebag exists."

                    lol
        • This post was deleted by MdJGutie
      • Re: peta's energies misplaced

        Mon, September 1, 2008 - 10:55 PM

        "when you solve human problems, animal problems virtually disappear."


        What? like no more animal glue and leather couches?

        • Re: peta's energies misplaced

          Tue, September 2, 2008 - 5:39 AM
          < What? like no more animal glue and leather couches? >

          I hear that. And it's a good point. But in the meantime, why does glue and upholstery outrank basic human suffering? Especially when fixing a human problem fixes other animal problems like neglect and cruelty--and improves the quality of lives for animals in general.
          • Re: peta's energies misplaced

            Tue, September 2, 2008 - 11:11 AM
            Why are you here? If you are so worried about human suffereing why are you wasting your energy trying to convince people that they are wasting theirs? Go help a human, or an animal or what ever, but stop wasting your time and ours by trying to convince us our energy is misplaced. This is where we choose to spend our energies, you can choose where to spend yours, but it seems like your just wasting it, arguing with people who already have a cause.
            • Unsu...
               

              YOUR energies misplaced

              Tue, September 2, 2008 - 12:05 PM
              How does animal glue and leather HELP humans? or prevent their suffering?

              Mickey, the leather industry destroys entire communities of HUMANS The toxins and pollutants in leather manufacturing causes 300% more cancer in areas with tanneries near by. Not to mention all sorts of respiratory and other diseases caused by the tanning...in case you didn't know leather and fur are made of skin, and unless they are treated these skins WOULD rot.
              and the same is true of the manufacturing of all those chemical animal byproducts.

              but unfortunately people like you always make those kind of arguments and the argument is flawed. because you are basing yourself on the fact that to care about other species means to not care about our own. But all species are related.

              Love and compassion are not like a pie with only limited pieces. They are unlimited. Yes everyone has a limited amount of time to devote to a cause. But those who crusade for the environemnt and then eat a steak: that steak does more damage than all the good that they did.
              Those who fight for children's rights, and then buy sweat shop clothing or leather: that leather has killed more children then all the good they have done.

              I am not saying that animal rights is for everyone. If you came to me and said that you didn't care for other species at all but you were vegan because it is the most responsible choice environmentally and for the survival of the HUMAN species and that you then choose to spend your enrgy with OTHER causes, like feeding the homeless, or housing the poor, or whatever. I would congratulate you. But if you are helping children, and then eating meat which will ensure that those very children's children will have no environment left to sustain them when they are your age, I would say you are misguided.

              and then you make the leap that those who care about animals care less about humans. How do you figure?

              As I said earlier anti-bullying programs and housing for the poor are wonderful causes. (although I did notice that you didn't name an actual organization or go into any detail which makes it hard to believe that you actually are involved in those causes)

              and considering that you joined a tribe of an organization that you don't belong to, and with whom you don't agree, solely for the purpose of giving a hard time to the members of that tribe, I think you don't really understand ANTI-bullying...quite the opposite.

              as I and other members have said before: If you don't like PETA, don't support them, no one is forcing you. And if you don't agree with how PETA spends their energy then why don't YOU spend your energy differently? BE THE CHANGE THAT YOU WANT TO SEE IN THE WORLD

              I can tell you that if you created an organization who's purpose was to teach teenagers about pacifsm and non-violence, and kindness to fellow human beings and also made the connection to animals, I would totally support that....oh wait isn't that PETA2 ;-) ???

              The reality is that idiots like you (you can add that to douchebag btw ;-) do NOTHING to help anyone, and have NO CAUSE but like to tell others who are making the world a better place that you would do things differenty, if only you weren't so busy drinking beer and smoking joints.

              I remember, about two years ago, I needed a special style of dress pants for a gig that I had. And my wife and I were going around trying to find that type of slack made of natural fibres (I don't like synthetics for environmental reasons) and of course made of no animal products...which should have been easy we could have just gone to the Gap, but we also wanted to make sure to find clothing that was fair labour ansd sweat shop free, so made in Canada or with some kind of assurance.

              unfortunately everywehere we went everythng was made in China. Finally we ended up at "Le Château" and found a pair of pants that were made in Canada.

              and the clerk asked us about wool (the whole : "but you don't kill the sheep for the wool argument", well I won't bore you with our response but it was basically this: www.vegsource.com/jo/qa/qawool.htm )
              and when we mentionned animal rights he said (like Mickey) "I care more about humans."

              to which I smiled and said "That's great! what do you do to help humans?", he stuttered and blushed and had no answer... and then I asked him where his shirt was made? did he know. who made it? did he care?

              Meanwhile HE cares more about humans but my wife and I had been shopping for over 4 hours and had visited at least 30 stores AND we were willing to pay an extra 100 dollars for a pair of pants because it was made in Canada in a factory where the workers were well treated.

              I also asked him what human causes interested him and (like Mickey) he mentionned some half-assed and very vague things about housing rights, and fair wages. So I asked him if he had been at demo last year about equal wages for women (most people don't know that even in Canada most women make only 70cents or less on the dollar compared to men) ...he hadn't heard about it.

              I then told him about the "peace sign" demonstration that was coming up and another demo against deportation from no one is illegal, and then that the following month there was a demo against homelessness, and perhaps he wanted information to go to those actions.

              he declined.

              ;-)

              those who say that they care more about humans need to SERIOUSLY ask themselves : how is my eating meat helping humans?
              How is feeding 70% of our grain and 60% of our water to animals while humans die of thirst and of starvation, HELPING HUMANS?

              How is allowing fishing and aqualculture industries to destroy our oceans and clear cut our natural mangroves, thereby causing storms to destroy coastlines and kill hundreds of thousands of people, clear cutting forests to make room for grazing animals thereby increasing storm activity and CAUSING Katrina and now Gustav...how does THAT help humans?

              the reality is there is only two category Mickey: those who care and those who don't. and you DON'T.

              But you could. And if you were honest and you really WERE concerned about the survival of the HUMAN species you would be vegan for that reason alone.

              Now as Erika asked: Why are you here? This tribe is for PETA members to discuss PETA activities , suggestions and ideas. You are NOT a PETA member and you are not an animal activist, so you are a TROLL.

              Do you also go to holocaust survivor forums and start posting about how you think the holocaust didn't happen? Do you go to feminist tribes and tell the women to "stay in the homes"?

              you are entitled to EVERY ONE of your opinions even the psychotic ones, but don't come into OUR HOUSE and expect us to tolerate your bullshit.
              • This post was deleted by MdJGutie
                • Unsu...
                   

                  Re: YOUR energies misplaced

                  Wed, September 10, 2008 - 8:20 PM
                  THIS TRIBE as explained in the description is for people who are members and SUPPORTERS of PETA.

                  why are you still here badger?

                  Do you also join feminists tribe and preach sexism?
                  Anti-racism tribes and preach racism?

                  • This is the maximum depth. Additional responses will not be threaded.
                    Unsu...
                     

                    Re: YOUR energies misplaced

                    Wed, September 10, 2008 - 9:03 PM
                    Plus if your source is PENN and TELLER (magicians) you are more idiotic that I previously thought.

                    Here's the REAL deal once and for all:

                    Does PETA euthanize animals? Yes. Because people call them every day about animal cruelty cases and they show up to people's backyards and find dogs tied to a chain one foot long, with no food and water, mange and open sores. The "owners" of these animals are low-life scum who don’t care one way or another.

                    There is a lot of dogfighting in Virginia. and also a LOT of kill shelters where the mode of killing the animal is stuffing as many of them in a huge footlocker, and then plugging a car exhaust to the locker.

                    There was even one town where there was a fenced-in abandoned lot and people started driving by and THROWING dogs over the fence...after a few weeks there were at least 20 dogs in that abandoned lot...and the sheriff was called to shoot them. This sheriff HATED doing this, but had to (ordered by city council) He called PETA distraught and PETA came and tried to heal those that they could and tried to place the animals.

                    (by the way if you ever actually GO to PETA headquarters Badger, you will see that there are cats and dogs EVERYWHERE. Each PETA staffer has AT LEAST two animals at home...and PETA is always looking for foster homes and trying to adopt out animals. But there is SOO much cruelty (primarily because of selfish morons like you and Penn and Teller) that they don't even make a dent.

                    And ASSHOLES like you are REAL quick to blame PETA, but what have YOU done to help stop the Pet population? The problem is not PETA the problem is all the companies who BREED animals and sell them to morons LIKE YOU who just dump them in the trash and then someone calls PETA and then if PETA euthanizes the cat that YOU abandoned THEY are the bad guys.... talk about passing the buck!
                    It's like if the salvation runs out of food to feed the homeless and you turn around and say that it is the salvation army's fault that the homeless are starving to begin with. IDIOT!

                    Plus idiots who don't spay or neuter their animals and then the population balloons. I am personally working to spay and neuter a feral cat colony that has grown to over 40 cats in just ONE SEASON just because two IDIOTIC neighbors had four cats each and did not have them spayed and neutered...and do these MORONS want to take responsibility for the 40+ cats??? of course not. We even had to go in there and spay and neuter their cats FOR THEM because they are such fucking losers that they won't even pay to spay and neuter their "pets" themselves...but they ALL have money to buy LOTS of beer.

                    And now WE are left with the task of rounding up over 40 cats, spaying and neutering them and trying to get them adopted. And almost EVERY DAY when I am out there trying to catch the cats, some FUCKWAD like you stops by and tells me that I should just "leave the cats alone" "Why are you bothering the cats" "that is animal cruelty!"

                    Meanwhile these fuckers, Like you and Penn and Teller (wearing their full-on leather suits and eating only meat) are HUGE rotten flesh eaters and don't give a flying fuck if the city comes in there and captures all the animals and kills them...or if the animals just die of frost over the winter.

                    yeah...blame PETA for you inactivity Badger. It's really PETA's fault that idiots breed "pets" and don't take responsibility for them. yeah! ok.

                    So in the case of the "spent" dogs from the dog fighting rings thrown over the fence, PETA had to euthanize most of those dogs, But being given a last meal and euthanized with kindness, is WAY better than being stuffed in a box and gassed or shot in the face….of course the BEST solution would be to give those dogs homes…but DO YOU want to pay to house those dogs? huh Badger? What do you do when people show up at your door with ten dogs, and then ten more? and then 1000? How many can YOU take in???

                    But yeah, it’s just way easier to blame PETA. Don’t Blame Petco, and all the breeders, and the dogfighting rings, yeah blame PETA.
                    And make sure to get all your facts from Vegas performers like Penn and Teller….yeah, that makes sense!

                    As for the situation in "PETA kills animals" it was exactly that situation: dogs leftover from a dog fighting ring that PETA had no room for and had to euthanize... and NO ONE blames the fuckers who discarded the dogs to begin with…these were not PETA’s dogs…they were dogs that LOSERS like you and Penn and Teller didn’t care about and all of a sudden it’s PETA’s job to kill them FOR you.

                    PETA hires a company that picks up their dead animals and incinerates them (because they don’t want the animals rendered into cat and dog food…cuz well, cats and dogs should not be eating cats and dogs) but this incineration service is expensive and they don’t stop by at PETA headquarters everyday…since these were unscheduled euthanizations and it happened before a long weekend, the staffers made the mistake of dumping the bodies in the trash... the dogs were already dead, I doubt they cared where their bodies were dumped. So the staffers made a mistake. That's all.

                    There is no cruelty and PETA was NEVER indicted for animal cruelty, they were charged with improper disposal of dead animals or some shit like that. Get your facts straight douchebag!

                    NOW PLEASE could all the PETA haters LEAVE this tribe?? This tribe is for PETA members. What the fuck is wrong with all you losers? You don't have friends of your own that you have to join a tribe just to harass its members???

                    If you don't like PETA then LEAVE THIS TRIBE.

                    Please could all REAL PETA members just simply post after me the following bolded words:

                    ALL PETA HATERS PLEASE LEAVE THIS TRIBE.
                    • Re: YOUR energies misplaced

                      Wed, September 10, 2008 - 9:09 PM
                      I'm somewhat shocked that you think that should pass for acceptable logic.

                      Then again, when I brought data, you brought insults, invectives, and a lot of text which suggests to me that you're the type of person that will raise whatever defenses are available to keep a perfectly valid idea out. Kinda like the "weapons of mass destruction" defense. Just because you proclaim a thing to be true, doesn't make it true. And as I said, I have data.

                      I've checked, and I was right: peta does not want you to keep pets. From their website, the same one you pointed me to: "...we believe that it would have been in the animals' best interests if the institution of "pet keeping"—i.e., breeding animals to be kept and regarded as "pets"—never existed. The international pastime of domesticating animals has created an overpopulation crisis; as a result, millions of unwanted animals are destroyed every year as "surplus." This selfish desire to possess animals and receive love from them causes immeasurable suffering, which results from manipulating their breeding, selling or giving them away casually, and depriving them of the opportunity to engage in their natural behavior. Their lives are restricted to human homes where they must obey commands and can only eat, drink, and even urinate when humans allow them to."

                      All that being said. I'm still not going to insult you. I deplore animal cruelty. I support animals by helping humans live better lives.
                    • Re: YOUR energies misplaced

                      Wed, September 10, 2008 - 9:10 PM
                      Keep yelling Antoine. Complacency is what has brought the western world to the sorry state it's in. God forbid someone ask you to think.
                      • Unsu...
                         

                        Re: YOUR energies misplaced

                        Wed, September 10, 2008 - 9:28 PM
                        And how are you helping the western world get better Mickey? with your imaginary charitable deeds?

                        Here's a logic question for you. You do not like or even agree with PETA: so why are you here?
                        this tribe is for PETA members and supporters of PETA. Why did you join this tribe?

                        There is only ONE possibility: YOU ARE A TROLL.

                        LEAVE.

                        Again your idiocy knows no bounds. What you quoted makes from the PETA makes perfect sense and in no way contradicts ANYTHING that I wrote...it does not expose any kind of hypocrisy at all...PETA has beliefs as we all do, but they are also RESPONSIBLE ( as YOU are NOT)

                        What Peta is saying is that pet animals (cats, dogs, bunnies, birds, fish, etc) WOULD have benefited greatly if we (humans) had not made them into pets to BEGIN WITH...can you argue that? Have you seen a shelter or a humane society? Have you seen how full they are? Have you seen pet shops?... Do you know how many pet animals are killed by animal control agencies EVERY YEAR????

                        But PETA also live in the REAL world. And because of the world that we live in it is OUR (human) responsibility to take care of as many "pet" animals as we can...while promoting spaying and neutering and the stopping of ALL breeding of animals for sale.

                        Now you can keep saying over and over that my logic doesn't make sense...you can keep posting things from teh PETA website to try to prove me wrong...but PETA HAS NO SECRET AGENDA.... and neither do I.

                        we seek TOTAL ANIMAL LIBERATION.
                        And a day when everyone believes that animals are NOT OURS to use for ANY EXPLOITIVE PURPOSE!

                        but until then of course we will do ALL that we can to help the institutionalized animals that are alive in this REAL world.

                        NOW. AGAIN.

                        YOU ARE NOT A PETA MEMBER OR A PETA SUPPORTER.

                        PLEASE LEAVE THIS TRIBE. (and take the idiot Badger with you and any other PETA hater)
                        • Re: YOUR energies misplaced

                          Thu, September 11, 2008 - 5:14 AM
                          What imaginary charitable deeds? You asked me early on what I did to better the world, and I told you. Would you like to see my linkedin profile? A list of the nonprofit boards I serve? I have been nothing less than genuine with you.

                          And I genuinely wish people would stop supporting an organization that has outlived its usefulness.
                          • Unsu...
                             

                            Re: YOUR energies misplaced

                            Thu, September 11, 2008 - 11:30 AM
                            SO LEAVE then.

                            So you have joined this TRIBE (that is a tribe for members and supporters of PETA) in order to tell the member to stop supporting PETA.

                            You had your say. WE are not interested NOW LEAVE.

                            and how mean spirited by the way to join a group ONLY for the reason of telling people NOT to support that group.

                            I doubt highly that you counsel anyone on anti-bullying because what you are doing IS bullying. What I am doing is fighting back against a bully: YOU!

                            LEAVE!!!!!
                            • Re: YOUR energies misplaced

                              Fri, September 12, 2008 - 12:01 PM
                              Dude Mickey... seriously, are you even reading his posts? You keep saying he is being illogical, what exactly are you referring to? Everything Antoine has said has been perfectly logical. Seriously, help us out here?
                              • Unsu...
                                 

                                Re: YOUR energies misplaced

                                Sat, September 13, 2008 - 6:27 AM
                                Thanks Matt.
                                And for those who don't have the patience to read my long posts:
                                PeTA is not at all anti-"pet" although PeTA prefers to call them companion animals or animal companions...since the term "pet" implies servitude:
                                www.helpinganimals.com/animal...end.asp

                                as for the PHILOSOPHY of not using animals even as companions, that is FOR THE FUTURE.
                                for RIGHT NOW though it is our responsibility to take care of all the animals that we can.
                                But ALWAYS adopt from shelters or rescues NEVER BUY from a pet shop or a breeder.
                                In fact ask your pet shops to stop selling live animals.
                                ALWAYS take good care of your animal (learn how on the PeTA website above)
                                ALWAYS spay and neuter your animal.

                                And remember that the animal is an individual with whom you are building a relationship, an inter-species relationships can be challenging, he or she is NOT a commodity, an accessory or a surrogate child.
                                • This post was deleted by MdJGutie
                                  • Unsu...
                                     

                                    Re: YOUR energies misplaced

                                    Sat, September 13, 2008 - 3:56 PM
                                    ahhh...insightful and articulate as usual.
                                    Badger and Mickey and others, I don't understand why you guys visit tribe.
                                    I like coming to tribe because all the tribes that I belong to are about topics that interest me and i like reading posts by other members and also contributing to the topic that I LIKE.

                                    you guys join a tribe that you DISAGREE with just to piss off all its members....I don't understand why someone would do that.

                                    I don't join the steak lover's tribe, or the fly fishermen tribe.

                                    When I log on to tribe it is with a smile on my face in the hopes that I will learn something new or read something interesting. You guys log on to tribe for something negative only. I don't get that.

                                    If you don't like PETA then don't join the PETA tribe. And if you only enjoy tribe to troll and to piss others off, I suggest that A. you don't get what tribe is about and B. you need therapy.
                                    • Re: YOUR energies misplaced

                                      Sat, September 13, 2008 - 7:24 PM
                                      >I don't join the steak lover's tribe, or the fly fishermen tribe.

                                      Yet, as an 'activist' organization PeTA is, in the default world, among the first to condemn, interrupt and malign such organizations because their ideals are contrary to the simplistically myopic agenda of its extremist base.

                                      Another chalk mark in your hypocrisy column Antoine.
                                      • Unsu...
                                         

                                        Re: YOUR energies misplaced

                                        Sat, September 13, 2008 - 7:44 PM
                                        BADGER!!!!!

                                        THIS is a PETA tribe.
                                        YOU don't HAVE to join.

                                        This tribe is for PETA supporters...If you dislike PETA than start a "I hate PETA tribe"...but don't come on THIS tribe to spread anti-PeTA propaganda. There is NOTHING supportive about any of your GARBAGE posts.


                                        Mickey. Since you are so fond of logic:

                                        let me give you a parallel:

                                        Going to a neighborhood meeting to discuss an idea that the neighborhood committee is not willing to discuss, is in fact presenting a differing view, and I would applaud you for it.

                                        however going to a neighborhood meeting of a neighborhood where you DO NOT live to tell the people gathered there that their neighborhood sucks and that they should all move out and move to your neighborhood...is not presenting a differing view...it is HARASSMENT.

                                        you are NOT a PETA member.

                                        that a meat-eating sociopath who joins tribes ONLY to bash its members is saying that *I* am not open to other views is laughable.

                                        You are not presenting any views, you are coming on the tribe for the People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals and saying that they should not help animals anymore and that their work is irrelevant.

                                        If you came here with GENUINE ideas on how PETA should spend its energies and GENUINE demonstration and action ideas, that would be supportive, but you come here for the SOLE purpose of basically saying "PETA sucks."

                                        you are a troll a bully and a loser.

                                        GO AWAY!!!
                                        • Re: YOUR energies misplaced

                                          Sun, September 14, 2008 - 5:20 AM
                                          I was a peta member.
                                          • Unsu...
                                             

                                            Re: YOUR energies misplaced

                                            Sun, September 14, 2008 - 8:05 AM
                                            Really? I HIGHLY doubt that.
                                            You are as much a PETA member as you actually volunteer for Habitat for Humanity.
                                            If you were a PETA member what was your PETA membership number?

                                            And if you were a PETA member, well you aren't one anymore, so GO AWAY.
                                            If you feel that PETA is no longer relevant than leave this tribe and join the "imaginary charities tribe" to help you in all your good work. :-)

                                            By joining here as someone who is against PETA you are a TROLL.

                                            As per the accusation that I refuse to hear differing viewpoints, I already gave the town meeting analogy. But here's another explanation. I would have NO PROBLEM if the PETA critics actually criticized PETA on legitimate issues, like their pandering to the medias and to famous people, like their often gratuitous nudity campaigns...etc...

                                            And in fact I have OFTEN discussed these issues in length with people. But those who criticize PETA on this tribe are always basing themselves on lies and ignorance.
                                            I mean Penn and Teller! Please!

                                            Which just proves how wrong you are. You can't find anything legitimate to criticize about PeTA so you latch on to some insane rumor and USE that to attempt to discredit them.

                                            Let's use humor for examples. I don't have to make something up or invent anything to make fun of George W. or fundamentalists, hunters, or McDonald's because the truth is horrible and hilarious... if you have to invent something to make a joke, then your joke sucks! If you have to invent something to criticize someone than your criticism is not valid.

                                            two examples:

                                            example1: Dane Cook comedy sketch he was making fun of an atheist by saying that the atheist believes that he will become a tree (so that Dane cook could make the joke that he would cut down the tree, turn it into paper and print a bible on it) only ONE problem, atheist don't believe that they become trees.

                                            Jerry Seinfeld observe REAL things which is why he was so funny.

                                            example2: Baby mama (horrible movie anyway but...) Tina Fey is so rampantly anti-vegetarian that she will use any excuse to make fun of us. But int his movie she only exposed her poor writing skills and her IGNORANCE. Her and her love interest go on a first date at a raw vegan restaurant, and the waiter brings them a YEAST BALL...that is not even raw! and it isn't EVEN real!!! I'm not raw, but actually in my experience raw vegan restaurants are the most impressive both in culinary prowess, taste and presentation! But idiotic meat-eaters do that all the time, because if they can prove that vegan food is disgusting than their selfish and cruel behvaiour is somehow justified.

                                            the fact is if you want gross, you don't need to look further than any fast-food joint, and again you don't need to make anything up...

                                            There are many things that one COULD criticize about PETA. And if that person was a REAL PETA member they would know these things, instead of spreading bullshit about how PETA is against pets and indicted for animal cruelty.

                                            Mickey, your arrogance is MIND-BOGGLING. It's like a drug addict trying to convince a doctor that he has not been using. DUDE! this guy is a doctor, he can tell!
                                            Likewise I am a REAL PETA member, so when you PRETEND to be a PETA member, I CAN TELL. Because you clearly know NOTHING about PETA.
                                            • Re: YOUR energies misplaced

                                              Sun, September 14, 2008 - 9:31 AM
                                              I told you the truth. I've told you my truth. You asked and each time I have given it. Your only defense is to be long winded and to bury a set of reasonable statements.
                                              • Unsu...
                                                 

                                                Re: YOUR energies misplaced

                                                Sun, September 14, 2008 - 8:09 PM
                                                Okay here's the short answer then Mickey:
                                                You are OBVIOUSLY no longer a PETA member.

                                                You now believe that PETA is irrelevant.

                                                so GO AWAY!

                                                THIS TRIBE IS FOR PETA MEMBERS AND THOSE WHO WISH TO SUPPORT PETA. LEAVE THIS TRIBE.
                                                • Re: YOUR energies misplaced

                                                  Sun, September 14, 2008 - 8:22 PM
                                                  Tribe in general is for discussions. You don't own it, and neither do I. You can yell all you want, but it's not going to change the content of anything I've peacefully presented.
                                                  • Unsu...
                                                     

                                                    Re: YOUR energies misplaced

                                                    Sun, September 14, 2008 - 8:29 PM
                                                    Mickey. even you can understand this:

                                                    YOU joined a tribe that supports a group for the SOLE purpose of saying that the group is irrelevant.

                                                    that is NOT discussion. That is harassment.
                                                    • Re: YOUR energies misplaced

                                                      Sun, September 14, 2008 - 8:48 PM
                                                      Your continuing, underhanded insults notwithstanding, harassment has some specific, legal definitions associated with it, and I meet none of them. I'm surprised you would suggest such a patently false thing, what with all the "facts" you have at your disposal. Your behavior might prompt one to think the ideas I'm putting on the table are personally wounding you in some way.




                                                      • Unsu...
                                                         

                                                        Re: YOUR energies misplaced

                                                        Sun, September 14, 2008 - 9:10 PM
                                                        From the description of TRIBE: "At tribe.net, we believe in the power of connecting to other people to get things done. (…) You can invite friends, search for people with similar interests, and join or create tribes (member-created online groups) dedicated to interests you might have. "

                                                        DEDICATED TO INTERESTS YOU MIGHT HAVE.

                                                        connecting to others to get things done: you are here only to say that what we and the group that we support is doing, is not valid...that is NOT helpful or even a BIT respectful.

                                                        The PETA tribe is described as: “For members of PETA (People for the Ethical Treatment of Animals) PETA operates under the simple principle that animals are not ours to eat, wear, experiment on, or use for entertainment."

                                                        YOU are NOT a PETA member. Nor do you even agree with ANYTHING that PETA does, as you have repeatedly stated that you believe that PETA is irrelevant and that those of us who support PETA (ie: members of THIS tribe) should support other groups instead.

                                                        You have gone further to misquote and denigrate PETA.

                                                        You are not REALLY interested in this tribe or the reason for this tribe. You joined this tribe ONLY to disagree with not an opinion posted on the tribe, or even with a differing viewpoint, but with the VERY EXISTENCE of the tribe.

                                                        Wikipedia defines a troll as: "An Internet troll, or simply troll in Internet slang, is someone who posts controversial and irrelevant or off-topic messages in an online community, such as an online discussion forum or chat room, with the intention of provoking other users into an emotional response or to generally disrupt normal on-topic discussion."

                                                        In the case of tribe, the topic of THIS tribe is to support PETA. You are therefore by definition OFF topic.

                                                        This website is also good : communitiesonline.homestead.com/de...tml
                                                        That’s you in the picture, by the way, and I believe that you fall into the category of destructive troll. Since you are against the very GROUP that this tribe represents.

                                                        Most people see trolling as harassment. Joining a Christian tribe to say that Jesus never existed, or joining a model car enthusiast tribe to say that collecting model cars is stupid, or joining a PETA tribe to say that PETA is no longer a relevant group…is not conversation, it is not contributing to the tribe…it is destructive troll behavior.

                                                        And it IS harassment.
                                                        • This post was deleted by MdJGutie
                                                        • This post was deleted by MdJGutie
                                                          • This post was deleted by MdJGutie
                                                            • This post was deleted by MdJGutie
                                                              • This post was deleted by MdJGutie

Recent topics in "PETA"

Topic Author Replies Last Post
Badger and the Code of Conduct En Transit /... 6 June 20, 2009
Gophers 5 June 16, 2009
VegCamp at burning man VegCamp 3 May 8, 2009
A SPIRITUAL C * NSP * R* CY Pierre 0 April 16, 2009